Hello dear
Welcome To Paul & Eddy's Pizza
Welcome to Paul & Eddy's Pizza, a beloved gem located in Hamden, CT. Renowned for its outstanding flavors, this small pizzeria captures the essence of pizza artistry. Their dough stands out, avoiding the yeasty taste common in many pizzerias. Signature pies like the Chicken Marsala and classic Marguerita delight the palate with fresh ingredients and creativity. Patrons rave about the freshness and quality in every bite, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers, whether you're a local or just passing through. Experience the passion and flavor that keeps customers coming back for more at Paul & Eddy's Pizza.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Ziti With Meatballs
Turnover (Large)
Dough To Go
Mozzarella (Medium)
About
Paul & Eddy's Pizza
Welcome to the delightful world of Paul & Eddy's Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in Hamden, Connecticut. Located at 1919 1630 Whitney Ave, this charming pizzeria has been making waves with its incredible flavors and welcoming atmosphere. With a phone number of +1 203-230-9396, calling ahead might just be the push you need to treat yourself to their delicious offerings.
As I stepped into Paul & Eddy's, I was immediately struck by the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza. The foundation of their menu is undoubtedly the pizzas, which range from classic cheese slices at just $2.50 to large mozzarella pizzas at $20.00. The dough is light and flavorful, a fact echoed by loyal customers who rave about its non-yeasty taste. It's a dough that sets the stage for an extraordinary pizza experience.
But the pizza isn't the only star of the show. Their side offerings, such as meatballs and cheese to go for $6.00, perfectly complement the main event. And if you're in the mood for something different, the array of salads, from the Greek Salad with feta to the hearty Antipasto Salad, provides fresh, vibrant flavors that balance the indulgence of pizza.
Fans of subs and wraps will also find a home here. The BBQ Chicken Wrap, loaded with smoky goodness, is a must-try, while the Chicken Parm sandwich showcases their commitment to quality with juicy fried chicken, marinara, and melted mozzarella atop a fresh Italian roll—all for just $12.00.
Customers have been vocal about their love for Paul & Eddy's. From heartfelt nostalgia—like Edward Varipapa, who fondly remembers getting pizza there every Friday in school—to newcomers who declare it their go-to pizza spot since moving to Connecticut, the reviews speak volumes. With mentions of flavors that rival renowned New Haven locations and specific praises for unique offerings like the clam casino pizza, it's clear that Paul & Eddy's isn't just another pizzeria; it’s a local treasure.
Overall, Paul & Eddy's Pizza is more than just a meal; it's an experience steeped in community and flavor. Each slice tells a story, and every dish has the power to evoke memories, making this establishment a must-visit for any pizza aficionado. If you're looking to satisfy your cravings, this is where you'll want to be. Trust me, you won’t regret it!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This little place have one of the best pizza i had. The pizza dough don't taste like yeast. Great pizza. ”
“ Great place. Every time my band plays in town this is the place we hit. And I grew up near this area and have been to the "Big 3" many times. This place is a great hidden gem. ”
“ Remember when place first open. Small pizza place with big flavor... Can not go wrong with anything you order here it's fresh and very good. Give those new haven pizzas a run for their money ”
“ One of the best pizzas of all time! I now live in Austin TX and routinely crave a slice from here. Been coming since 2001! Was served this every Friday at school for lunch and was a local customer for 18 years. One of the only places that is a must go when I come home. The clam casino is offf the charts. ”
“ So I moved to Connecticut last year and I’ve been looking for new pizza places to try. I’ve had some of the well-known places in the New Haven area which were pretty good. I wanted to try and find a good place closer and driving past I saw it and decided to stopped in. Up to this point I would have to say Paul and Eddie’s has the BEST PIZZA that I’ve tried since I’ve moved here. Moving forward they will be my definitive go to when I’m craving the best pizza in the area. ”
“ BEST. PIZZA. EVER!! We are obsessed and get their pizza once a week without fail! The texture of the crust is perfect and it’s just overall amazing! Sometimes pizza can be thinner or thicker than normal and can be a little burnt in some places so consistency isn’t always there but it’s still so yummy so to us the pros definitely outweigh cons! Highly recommend! ”
“ I used to go here all the time throughout my childhood and Paul and eddy’s is one of my fondest memories!! My grandmother lived 2 houses down the street and when I would come in to visit from Arizona this was my first stop. Highly recommended from coast to coast ”
“ I've been here in Hamden almost 5 years now.....what an absolute shame I didn't find these guys sooner!! Nobody has better pizza in this town and it's not even close!! Ordered white brocolli pizza and a regular cheese pizza and my son and I are in heaven watching football with this. Great job guys! ”